It’s a Sunday evening, I’m sat on the club style velour chair. It’s gray, my feet are up on the mismatched ottoman. The sounds of my crackling iceball knocking about in my Laphroaig fill the room and accompany the oaky smoke on the palate. As I glance down at my wrist and contemplate the watch I’m reviewing, I think back to 2018. A younger man, with a drained savings account to move to the UK. Riding his Schwinn to meet the train to take him into Cardiff for a 9 am start. Broke but burning with ambition. One day while riding that cold train, I wrote a verse on my phone for a rap track I’d never finish. I remember the lyrics:

“my birthday

my wife, might cop your guy the Black Bay

and I wonder why…”

At that time, I was brand new to the world of watches. Like many others, I had fallen into the rabbit hole of Teddy Baldassarre videos and endless forums. Tudor, then, was in a transitional phase. Less focused on in-house movements, still wearing their oversized crown stems, and dials that bore the cult classic, Tudor rose. There was something charming about that, a bit like revisiting a paperback first edition.

I’d fallen for the original Black Bay. Not the Black Bay Fifty-Eight, not even the dive-homage “Heritage” piece. Just the regular, old-school Black Bay. That feels like a lifetime ago. But back then, this was the watch. Just look up the Watchcastage video comparing the Black Bay to the Rolex Explorer. It was a close head-to-head, and this Tudor was its spiritual successor.

By 2020, the Black Bay craze had hit full stride. Dive watches became gospel. Chronographs and dress watches? Forgotten. It was all worn aluminium bezels and gilt dials. Even the Longines HydroConquest, once the default for quiet professionals and retirees, had to evolve or die. The Black Bay had rewritten the rulebook.

Since then, my tastes have matured. I’ve become even more of a Bond aficionado.

A measure of Connery, two dashes of Fleming, and always garnish: a nod to Everest and the Explorer. That’s why I bought the Tudor Heritage Ranger when I did. I loved its spirit, but the proportions? Off. My wife once glanced at it on my wrist and quipped, “It looks like a dinner plate.” That watch was up for sale by the weekend.

And in its absence, there was a gap. I missed having something rugged. I missed having something that whispered of a different era but could still hold its own in this one. So, I picked up a vintage Tudor Oyster Prince (ref. 7965). Beautiful, yes. Gentlemanly, certainly. But it lacked the muscle. A watch for cocktails, not confrontation.

Which brings me to the Tudor Black Bay Dark. I’m halfway through a 30-day wear challenge, and it’s time to talk. You won’t find lug measurements or exhaustive spec sheets here. I’m not that kind of wearer. I care about the story: what the watch means, not just what it is.

First Impressions: A Watch With Teeth

This is a watch that says two things, and only two things: rough and tumble. This isn’t a fashion piece. It’s a luxury bruiser, the kind of thing you could picture Usyk wearing to a state dinner. “The younger brother who’s almost as good-looking but can ski backwards with a cigar in his mouth.”

Would someone ever be mugged for this watch? Doubt it. The man wearing it looks like trouble. You’d clock the large PVD case and think twice.

It wears like a modern Rolex Maxi case: slab-sided, bold, unapologetically thick. But it works. This is the first 41mm watch I’ve owned that doesn’t feel oversized. The proportions hit right. It’s thicker than my MacBook, but that’s precisely the appeal. It looks bombproof, like it would hurt you before you had the chance to hurt it.

Dial, Bezel, and That Casino Royale Charm

Let’s talk design. The anodised aluminium bezel has been called a poker chip. And ever since a friend said that, I haven’t been able to unsee it. But as a Casino Royale fan, that only makes me like it more.

There’s a red triangle at the lume pip, pure Connery. It nods back to older Rolex Submariners and greater men. The white lume plots pop beautifully against a matte, lightly textured dial. And the text, “Chronometer Officially Certified”, reminds you this is no toy. Sure, it’s not a METAS-certified Master Chronometer. But frankly? It doesn’t need to be. This piece has kept perfect time since arriving from Watchfinder. That’s good enough for me.

The snowflake hands, with their oversized lume plots and angular design, offer a perfect counterpoint to the classic dial layout: triangle at 12, batons at 3, 6, and 9. This is Tudor forging its own path, not just copying Rolex, but referencing history while carving out its own legend. That’s the new way of Tudor, and they’re currently my favourite brand because of it. It’s not a poor man’s Rolex, it’s the Rolex that you’re not afraid to knock about. Sure, you could buy a Seiko for that, or you could stay upmarket.

Thanks for reading Brendon’s Substack! This post is public, so feel free to share it and support the work.

Straps, Snicks, and Snacks

Mine’s on the hybrid leather-rubber strap. It’s calfskin on top with rubberised backing. Practical and stylish. The clasp? Milled, blacked-out, and fitted with a secondary security lock. As the 1916 Company might say: it offers a very satisfying snick and snack. You’ll know what I mean the first time you fasten it.

I avoided the bracelet version. PVD-coated steel can scratch badly, and I didn’t want the added weight. This strap keeps things streamlined. Pull on a black leather jacket, and the whole thing just sings. You’ve become every woman’s biker-boy fantasy. Effortless. Lethal. Cool.

Other nerdy bits? Well, it has an in house movement, it makes no difference to me. It gets 70 hr power reserve though, which is handy and it has a nice sweep at 4Hz. These are of great importance to me.

Final Thoughts: Mission Accomplished

At 41mm, it’s the perfect wrong size. Larger than you’d expect, but just right once it’s on. There are watches I admire from a distance, and there are watches that I choose to live with. This one has become the latter. It’s not trying to impress anyone. It’s not delicate. It’s not dressed up. It’s ready to fight and then order a Vesper at the bar.

So here I am, 30 days in, 0007 on the wrist, remembering where I started and how far I’ve come. From rap lyrics on a train to writing this for Time 2 Live Again. From dreaming of a Black Bay to wearing the darkest version of it.

Some watches tell time.

This one tells my story.

Thirty days is a crush. A year is a relationship: Tudor Black Bay Dark: A Year On The Wrist.